Challenges and Solutions in Healthcare Data Quality Management

In the dynamically evolving healthcare system, information quality emerges as an essential aspect of delivering healthcare, conducting research, and decision-making. The advancement in technological solutions to collect, store, and analyze vast amounts of patient data in healthcare facilities has raised concerns regarding the quality and accuracy of the data. However, this mission is not without some challenges as will be discussed in the following papers.

There are several issues that impact the quality of data in the healthcare sector; these include the format of data, issues of data privacy, and lastly, issues of data culture. The eight major concerns that this article identifies with regards to healthcare data quality management and the suggestions for addressing these concerns listed in the article make it a useful reference for organizations that are attempting to enhance their data management.

1. Inconsistent Data Formats

This paper also found that the issue of data format inconsistency is still prevalent in healthcare data quality management. The realities show that healthcare organizations are faced with myriad systems and sources from which to obtain and archive patient information. There is often a situation when one can observe that Electronic Health Records, laboratory systems, imaging devices, and numerous other varieties of healthcare technologies may have their own way of data storage and exchange.

Such a situation has a detrimental impact on the integration, analysis, and interpretation of data collected from the various studies. For instance, one may record blood pressure as ‘120/80’ while the other records it as ‘120-80,’ which in effect increases the difference and the margin of error between one system and the other. In addition, differences in formatting of data may also hamper the exchange of patient data between organizations thus degrading the quality of care.

To address this issue, healthcare organizations must maintain continuity and develop a single language used within the systems. There are two ways of achieving interoperability: HL7 and using SNOMED CT, which is the Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine – Clinical Terms for sharing of clinical data. By employing these standards, it becomes possible for organizations to adopt a common format and structure of data to support the improved readability of data in the systems and departments of the organization.

However, the assessment of mapping the data from the legacy systems into the standard formats using data mapping tools and mechanisms can also be useful in the process. This also enhances the quality of data as well as compatibility of data in a way that data can easily be transferred between different healthcare service providers to improve on the interphase of care for the patient. Other meetings such as how staff should follow format and terminologies that are put in place can also improve these practices in the organization.

2. Incomplete Data

Inadequate data is one of the biggest challenges that healthcare data quality management deals with because this leads to the development of gaps that can hinder the provision of quality healthcare to patients and quality analysis. This problem arises where some data is missing in the patient's records such as patient history, patient tests, or patient schedule for administration of drugs. Some of the causes of incomplete data include inaccurate entry of data, faulty entry gadgets or tools, and patients’ failure to recall or give all the information that is required.

The consequences of incomplete data are far-reaching: Clinicians may make decisions based on limited information, while researchers may make conclusions based on limited data, while on the other hand healthcare administrators may not have the ability to measure the true performance of their organizations effectively. Moreover, a lack of complete data is also problematic because healthcare providers have to incur time and effort in searching for the missing information.

To minimize the effects of this challenge of incomplete data, healthcare organizations should make sure that the organization has the right data collection methods and also should embrace the use of data collection that is automatic. It is possible to design data entry forms, with fields that have to be filled for the occurrence of certain events, and this helps ensure that all relevant information has been entered. In addition, the use of AIDC technologies, for instance, bar codes in delivery of medication or the use of speech recognition in charting of clinical notes reduces errors and omissions.

There is also the need for organizations to include features that notify the user on records that are incomplete for follow-up. Further, full data entry training for the healthcare staff and the same to the best practices can also improve the data quality. In addition, patient portals in which patients can see and update the data about the patient can also be helpful in addressing issues to do with missing records. By employing these strategies, healthcare providers can minimize the rate of incomplete information when used in patient care and in the decision-making processes of the organization.

3. Data Accuracy

Data accuracy is also one of the key subcategories of healthcare data quality management, an issue that has been encountered in many organizations. Some of the causes of inaccurate data include wrong input data entered by data entry clerks, wrong calibration of some medical equipment used in the measurement process, and problems that may arise in the course of data conversion. The negative outcomes of the existence of inaccurate information in medical activities are rather critical and can lead to death.

For instance, an error made in recording a medication dosage may result in wrong treatment; wrong diagnostic codes may result in wrong billing or even misrepresentation of health statistics. Moreover, if the information is incorrect then society may lose confidence in the healthcare facilities and in the same respect, any research studies that use this data may be rendered useless. Given the fact that data has increasingly become significant in healthcare, the accuracy of each piece of data is paramount in patient management, organizational operations, and advancement of medicine.

To improve the quality of data collected, it is recommended that healthcare organizations follow a comprehensive strategy that includes the use of data quality software, information technology, business process redesign, and staff education. There is much need to perform quality checks on the data to ensure that the data accuracy issues are corrected systematically through data quality audits. These audits can be done automatically to emphasize areas that could potentially be wrong by using certain rule sets such as values that are out of a specific range or where certain data fields do not correlate with other relevant data fields.

One of the key recommendations that can help to minimize the entry errors is the use of data validation rules that should be implemented during data entry. For instance, range checks may use a check to ensure the physiological possibility range of the vital signs of the patient, while format validators can use a check to ensure proper format of dates and identification numbers. Also, the support of detailed training to the healthcare personnel on how to enter data in the best way is also important. This training should be centered on such aspects as the reliability of the data, the errors that must be avoided, and the methods that can be used to verify the data that has been entered into the system.

To overcome the challenges of discrepancy, one has to implement a mechanism of conducting data verification on a regular basis with the objective of comparing the outcome with other sources of data. Healthcare organizations should promote data accuracy and prepare their staff for data accuracy to use credible data that will improve patient care and organizational decision-making.

4. Data Timeliness

Healthcare data timeliness is another aspect of data quality management that is relatively difficult at least most of the time. Decision-making in today’s world is fast, and thus the current information is the best between a good decision and a bad one. Real-time information is important in several aspects of medical practice, for example, in the observation of patients, identification of diseases, and the creation of therapies. However, many healthcare organizations are facing challenges in relation to delay in data entry, data processing, and data reporting.

Such delays can be occasioned by several factors; for example, the staff may be fully engaged in other tasks, the organization’s structure is inefficient in handling large volumes of information, and the current systems may only allow entry of data manually in a slow process. The penalties for timely data are tremendous; delayed treatments, no possibility for early detection, false reporting, and threats to patient safety. Furthermore, in the context of research and public health, delays in data access can compromise the timely response required to tackle new health threats or assess the efficacy of interventions.

Regarding data timeliness, measures that have to be taken by healthcare organizations involve the ability to collect and analyze data in real-time. Measures, which can be taken to make data entry efficient, include the following; allocation of time limits and guidelines when entering data into a system. Some of the solutions are the usage of bedside terminals or mobile devices where data can be entered at the point of care and thus reduce the time lag between data generation and data entry into the system.

In addition, organizations should leverage automated data integration solutions that allow for extraction of data from various sources and feeding to central databases in real-time. The determination of the time between the creation of data and its usability is referred to as data latency and is essential in determining where the data flow is most constrained. Another way of ensuring adherence to the data timeliness is to check the audited data timeliness frequency in order to know what changes are needed.

However, there is an opportunity to post some kind of alerts or notifications to an employee that some entries are already due. Predictive analysis that is offered by artificial intelligence and machine learning is quite helpful in telling where issues are going to occur and in this way, ensuring that the right data at the right time is dealt with. Hence, when healthcare providers prioritize timeliness, data consumers will receive the most current data to support decisions, improve patient care, and assist in research and public health interventions.

5. Data Security and Privacy

Preservation of the data and its confidentiality remain one of the major challenges in healthcare data quality management since such information is quite sensitive. Many medical-related organizations request and store personal and medical data which makes such organizations a target for hackers. Consequences that can occur when patient data is intruded include sharp loss of patient trust, legal repercussions, and fines. However, there are also the negative impacts of information sharing, for example, there are some problems related to the security and privacy of data that at times may lead to a lack of willingness by the different healthcare providers to share information, this may have an impact on the quality of care for patients.

This is made more difficult by the need to allow the data to be used for legitimate purposes while at the same time ensuring that it is protected from unauthorized access. The continuous integration of information technology in healthcare facilities makes the safety and security of patient data quite challenging and very vital.

To overcome these challenges, it is highly recommended that healthcare organizations have proper measures for data security and privacy in their organizations. This starts with solid technical safeguards, for instance, turnkey data encryption while at rest or in transit, multi-factor authentication when it comes to system access, and security audits from time to time to ensure all the openings have been closed. Implementing the principle of least privilege controls ensures that the staff members only access the data necessary in the course of their working duties.

Training of the staff on data security measures and policies and on the legal requirements regarding the privacy of data should be conducted regularly so as to enforce the data protection among the personnel. Some of the topics that should be included in this training are; how to identify the phishing scams, information about the patient, and the matter of confidentiality. For instance, compliance with the US HIPAA rules or Europe’s GDPR regulations is mandatory rather than desirable since it guarantees the quality of collected data and patients’ trust.

There should also be a clearly stated guideline on how to handle a breach so that the organization can quickly respond and notify all the required stakeholders should the organization have been breached. It is possible to use threat detection systems which are more enhanced and conduct penetration testing from time to time so that the vulnerabilities are closed before they are exploited. In terms of data integrity and security, healthcare organizations are in a position to guarantee the accuracy of stored data, patients’ rights to their data, and therefore, confidence from the public they serve.

6. Data Integration

Data integration is one of the main problems of healthcare data quality management because the information is collected from different sources, and it is difficult to combine it and make it easily understandable and usable. Applications and systems in healthcare organizations are often numerous and diverse, and all of them generate data. This may comprise electronic health record systems, laboratory information systems, radiology information systems, billing systems as well as other specialty applications. The problem here is how to consolidate such information sources in a manner that will retain the quality of data and exclude the duplication of data while at the same time incorporating all the details on the patient’s health and the organizational performance.

Deduplication Software can be used to help eliminate redundant data, ensuring that the information collected and stored in different systems is unified in format, names, and quality, thus reducing the problem of integration. Further, the integration of application systems that were not designed to be integrated with other systems and hence the so-called legacy systems will also present a challenge. If the data integration is not done properly, it may result in the overall healthcare organization working with incomplete and possibly siloed information that leads to suboptimal patient care, organizational performance, and missed opportunities for learning and development.

To overcome the challenges of data integration, healthcare organizations should find means of handling the challenges that are in data integration; therefore, should endeavor to develop good integration strategies to embrace good integration practices. These platforms should be able to extract data from various sources, process it, transform it into a format that the system can accept, and then load this data into a data repository or data mart. A master data management (MDM) system can be deployed to construct a central repository for these critical data elements that are employed in various linked datasets.

An example of this is HL7 FHIR (Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources) which is used in sharing data between systems in the healthcare sector. The tools that are used in mapping and transformation can also help in addressing such concerns as different terminologies and structures of the systems. It would also be advantageous to carry out data quality checks during data integration in order to deal with such problems as inconsistency or error before these problems occur in the integrated data. The periodical auditing of integrated data can ensure other ways are still being maintained and standards kept high.

It is also important to note that it is possible to achieve loosely coupled systems integration by applying API integration methodologies. However, it would be useful to focus one’s attention on cloud integration as the latter offers better prospects for the efficient processing of large amounts of data coming from different sources. As such, the focus on data integration as a key aspect can help healthcare organizations gain a broader perspective on their functioning and patients, as well as enhance the quality of their decisions and care delivery.

7. Data Governance

Data governance is one of the most important concerns in relation to managing the quality of healthcare data since it entails developing the correct management of the data throughout the organization. The information that is generated, used, and managed in the healthcare context is challenging to classify and the different types of participants involved in the generation, usage, and management of healthcare data make it challenging to govern it.

Lack of ownership and accountability: Another recurrent problem in most healthcare organizations is the absence of an organizational structure that could either own or take responsibility for data as an asset. Instead of having fixed rules in most cases on how one is supposed to come up with data, how the data is supposed to be stored, and how the data is supposed to be used, there is a gap in the quality of data as well as how the data is analyzed. Further, because of the dynamic increase in the use of technology in the health and medical industry, the policies and practices in governance can easily lag behind if not regularly updated. If there is weak data governance, then there are several issues that may occur, such as replications of data, ambiguity in the definition of data, and issues in legal compliance.

To overcome the challenges of data governance in healthcare organizations, they should adopt a data governance program that would act as a guideline in determining who is responsible for what in the whole process of managing the data. This program should start with the formation of a data governance committee which will comprise clinical, IT, legal, and administration departments among others. This committee should be responsible for providing and implementing data governance policies, standards, and controls in an organization.

Some of the best practices that should be incorporated in the governance framework include Data ownership and stewardship, data quality, data access and security, data management, and disposal. This means that a data catalog that captures a set of data assets and who is responsible for them and the regulation on how they can be utilized can be of great help. It is recommended to provide training and communication for all the personnel who work with data regarding data governance policies and their significance. Also, there should be ways to assess compliance with governance policies and measure the effect of governance on data quality.

The creation of a mechanism for the frequent revision of the governance policies guarantees that they are up to date with the changing technology and regulatory frameworks. If data quality becomes the responsibility of everyone across the healthcare organization it would enhance the overall quality of data, which can be achieved through the implementation of strong data governance.

8. Data Quality Culture

Making and maintaining a data quality culture may be one of the most significant challenges in healthcare data quality. Lack of culture of data quality in health care organizations: Majority of the healthcare organizations are not able to ensure that all the employees at the facility, including frontline caregivers and clerical staff, appreciate the significance of having good quality data. The healthcare sector is usually dynamic and therefore, the processes are characterized by the short-term interests that result from the buildup of data.

The challenge with such an approach is that members of staff may not place a premium on the quality of data as they regard data input or processing as an ancillary activity to their core business of treating patients. Also, the employees’ resistance to new changes and processes can also be a factor that hinders the improvement of data quality practices. It is, therefore, apparent that even when the best of data-quality technical solutions and governance structures are put in place, poor culture will triumph.

Lack of rationality to follow data quality protocols may lead to staff members practicing it sporadically and as such, generate low-quality data that impacts patients, organizational outcomes, and decision-making.

To overcome this challenge and ensure that healthcare organizations embrace a culture of data quality, it is important to implement strategies such as education, incentives, and improvement. First, all the staff of the organizations must be trained and educated about the importance of data quality and what should be done. This training should not only reflect technical aspects of data quality but also focus on the consequences of data quality on patient outcomes and organizational performance.

Managers should actively support data quality improvement activities and provide reminders and support for data quality at least on a weekly basis; data quality indicators should also be included in performance appraisals. People can be encouraged and motivated to improve data quality practices by introducing a recognition program in which staff members or entire departments are rewarded for good practices. Organizations should also ensure that there are ways through which the staff can give comments and recommendations on the flow of data quality and the procedures involved in it.

It is recommended to conduct data quality audits on a regular basis and share best practices and success stories to prove that accurate data is a valuable asset. Using examples, it might be beneficial to appoint data quality 'champions' in various departments so they can spread the best practices and be a point of contact within their own department. In this way, it is possible to state that the processes of data quality management should become an organizational culture where each employee of the healthcare organization is aware of how he contributes to the improvement and maintenance of the data quality to achieve the goal of providing the highest level of patient care and organizational efficiency.

Also read: What is AML Software and How is it Important to Businesses?

Conclusion

In conclusion, it is clear that the main issues in healthcare data quality management must be approached systematically and holistically. As such, healthcare organizations should work towards achieving data completeness and accuracy, consider time factors in data management, incorporate appropriate security measures, address integration issues, realize sound data governance, and promote data quality culture as ways of improving the quality of data. Such measures do not only enhance the quality of care tendered to patients and organization efficiency but also create avenues for advancement in research and evidence-based practice. As the complexities of the healthcare system persist to change, the quality of data will continue to play a significant role in providing the right patient care as well as in enhancing the advancement of medical information.

Ixsight offers Healthcare AML Software that ensures compliance and risk management in the healthcare sector. Alongside Sanctions Screening Software and AML Software are essential tools for managing regulatory compliance and mitigating risks. Data Scrubbing Software further enhances data quality, positioning Ixsight as a leading provider in the financial compliance industry.